CD Review: The BreakUp Society’s So Much Unhappiness, So little Time…

It seems that overwhelmingly, critics subscribe to the notion that one must suffer for his art. If that is not immediately evident in his art, than he is deemed unworthy of our attention. If that is true, then Ed Masley is one of those singer-songwriters who will always be a critic’s darling. In fact, he could be pop music’s answer to Sylvia Plath except a little more whiny.

His interesting tales of depressing lives, pathetic losers, and bittersweet breakups juxtaposed with their eminently hummable, infectious melodies make him unique. So Much Unhappiness, So Little Time, the new release from his current band, The Breakup Society, is consistent with his past efforts and albeit a little while spotty, has more than it’s share of memorable songs.

The LP gets off to a rocking start with the title song that, for Masley, is fairly upbeat. Don’t worry though, “Your Invitation to Quit” brings us right back down to that uncomfortable but familiar place between blame and regret. “The Upward Spiral” has a very catchy chorus and “The Next Reunion” totally debunks the misguided sentiment that you can always go home. “He’s Supportin’ the War” is another anti-war song and, as such is passe’ and not very interesting. That’s not be politically correct for me to say, I know. But it’s true.

Other highlights include a fine slice of powerpop entitled “Here Comes Floyd”, The Young Fresh Fellows tinged “8th Circle of Hell”, and the final cut, “She Doesn’t Cross Against the Light”.
Released in 2012, it very possible could have made an appearance on the past year’s “Best of” list had I known of it’s release a little earlier.

All in all, this is a pretty darn good record. Like the band’s first record, James at 35, there’s plenty of chiming guitars, great hooks, and memorable albeit depressing lyrics to entertain you between sessions with your therapist.